Just so anyone reading this is updated, here is what has happened so far:
The IM I got directed me to a live chat with a representative. They had me check the code in the phones which were not correct. They walked me through updating the code manually which made both phones "Active". Unfortunately I still could not make calls, texts, etc.
I reentered the live chat with a representative who then gave me a phone number and pin to call directly to a customer service representative. That rep then verified that my phones were active. Then he checked to see if the servicing wireless carrier (AT&T) had any current service outages in my area. He said there were and that I should continue to check over the next 24 hours and then call back if the problem wasn't resolved.
The next morning I found that AT&T provides a real time map of service outages online (
http://downdetector.com/status/att/map/). I checked and saw no problems in my service area so I called customer service again. This time, the service rep had me pull the sim cards and check the serial numbers on them. According the service rep, I had gotten the wrong sim cards with the phones. They are sending me new ones in the mail and promise to reset the clock on my 30 days when they are installed and working.
I will provide another update after I receive the sim cards to let everybody know if that resolved my problems.